Scattering-Type Scanning Near-Field Optical Microscopy (s-SNOM)
Overview
Scattering-Type Scanning Near-Field Optical Microscopy (s-SNOM) stands at the forefront of nanoscale imaging techniques, providing unprecedented resolution and sensitivity for studying materials and biological samples. This advanced microscopy technique utilizes the near-field optical interactions between a sharp metallic tip and a sample surface to achieve spatial resolutions beyond the diffraction limit of conventional optical microscopes. In this comprehensive article by Academic Block, we will explore the principles, instrumentation, applications, and recent advancements of s-SNOM, highlighting its pivotal role in nanoscience and nanotechnology.
Principles of s-SNOM
The fundamental principle underlying s-SNOM involves the interaction of light with a sharp metallic tip positioned within a nanometer-scale proximity of the sample surface. Unlike conventional far-field optical microscopy, which is limited by the diffraction of light, s-SNOM exploits the near-field region, where the electromagnetic fields decay rapidly with distance from the source. The metallic tip serves as a local probe, allowing for the excitation and detection of near-field optical signals with subwavelength resolution.
The interaction between the metallic tip and the sample can be understood through various mechanisms, including elastic scattering, inelastic scattering, and evanescent wave coupling. Elastic scattering involves the redirection of incident light by the sample without any change in energy, providing information about the sample's morphology. Inelastic scattering involves energy exchange between the incident light and the sample, offering insights into the sample's chemical composition. Evanescent wave coupling occurs when the metallic tip interacts with the evanescent field extending from the sample surface, allowing for high-resolution imaging.
Instrumentation of s-SNOM
The instrumentation of s-SNOM is a complex integration of optics, electronics, and precision mechanics. A typical s-SNOM setup consists of a tunable infrared laser source, an atomic force microscopy (AFM) platform, and a specialized near-field detection system. The infrared laser source provides the illumination necessary for near-field interactions, and its tunability allows researchers to explore a wide range of frequencies.
The AFM platform is crucial for maintaining a constant distance between the metallic tip and the sample surface. The metallic tip, typically made of materials such as gold or aluminum, is attached to a cantilever, allowing for precise positioning in the nanoscale regime. The AFM not only facilitates topographical mapping but also serves as a feedback mechanism to control the tip-sample distance during scanning.
The near-field detection system plays a pivotal role in capturing the scattered signals from the sample. Various detection schemes, such as heterodyne or homodyne detection, are employed to extract both amplitude and phase information from the scattered light. This information is then used to generate high-resolution images of the sample surface.
Applications of s-SNOM
s-SNOM finds application across a diverse range of scientific disciplines, owing to its ability to provide nanoscale imaging and spectroscopy. Some notable applications include:
-
Materials Science: s-SNOM has been instrumental in characterizing nanomaterials, including graphene, nanotubes, and 2D materials. Its capability to probe material properties with high spatial resolution has led to breakthroughs in understanding the electronic and optical behavior of advanced materials.
-
Biophysics and Life Sciences: In the realm of life sciences, s-SNOM has enabled researchers to study biological samples at the nanoscale, offering insights into cell structures, protein interactions, and lipid membranes. The non-invasive nature of s-SNOM makes it particularly valuable for studying delicate biological specimens.
-
Plasmonics and Nanophotonics: The ability of s-SNOM to resolve localized surface plasmon resonances has paved the way for advancements in plasmonics and nanophotonics. Researchers can study the interaction of light with nanostructures, leading to the development of novel devices for sensing, imaging, and communication.
-
Nanoelectronics: s-SNOM is instrumental in the characterization of nanoelectronic devices, providing crucial information about their structural and optical properties. This is particularly important for the development of next-generation electronics with nanoscale features.
Mathematical equations behind the Scattering Type Scanning Near-Field Optical Microscopy
The mathematical equations behind Scattering-Type Scanning Near-Field Optical Microscopy (s-SNOM) involve concepts from classical electromagnetism, optics, and signal processing. The fundamental principles of s-SNOM can be described by equations that govern the interaction between the near-field probe (usually a sharp metallic tip) and the sample, as well as the detection and analysis of the scattered light. Below, we'll explore some key equations related to s-SNOM:
Maxwell's Equations:
The foundation of any optical technique lies in Maxwell's equations, which describe the behavior of electromagnetic fields. In the context of s-SNOM, Maxwell's equations govern the propagation and interaction of light with matter.
∇⋅E = ρ / ε0 ;
∇⋅B = 0 ;
∇ × E = −∂B / ∂t ;
∇ × B = μ0 J + μ0 ε0 (∂E / ∂t) ;
Near-Field Interaction:
The near-field interaction between the metallic tip and the sample is typically modeled using classical electromagnetic theory. The tip-sample interaction induces changes in the amplitude and phase of the incident light.
Etotal = Eincident + Escattered ;
The scattered field (Escattered) contains information about the local optical properties of the sample.
Tip-Enhanced Scattering:
The scattered field can be enhanced by the presence of the metallic tip, leading to tip-enhanced scattering. This enhancement is often described in terms of a tip enhancement factor.
Escattered,enhanced = Tip Enhancement Factor × Escattered ;
Heterodyne Detection:
Heterodyne detection is commonly used in s-SNOM to extract both amplitude and phase information from the scattered light. This involves mixing the scattered signal with a reference signal at a slightly different frequency.
Mixed Signal = Escattered ⋅ cos(ωt) ⋅ cos((ω + Δω)t) ;
The mixed signal is then demodulated to extract information about amplitude and phase.
Data Analysis and Imaging:
The acquired data is processed to create images that represent the local optical properties of the sample. Signal processing techniques, such as Fourier transformation, are often employed to convert the acquired signals into spatially resolved images.
Image (x,y) = F−1{ Data(kx,ky) };
Here, F−1 denotes the inverse Fourier transform.
It's important to note that the specific mathematical formulations may vary based on the details of the experimental setup, the type of near-field microscopy being used, and the desired information to be extracted from the sample. The equations provided here offer a broad overview of the fundamental principles underlying s-SNOM. Advanced models may take into account factors such as the complex dielectric function of the sample and the detailed geometry of the tip.
Recent Advancements and Emerging Trends
The field of s-SNOM is dynamic, with continuous advancements and emerging trends shaping its trajectory. Some recent developments include:
-
Ultrafast s-SNOM: Advancements in laser technology have enabled the development of ultrafast s-SNOM techniques, allowing researchers to investigate dynamic processes at the nanoscale with femtosecond temporal resolution. This has opened new avenues for studying ultrafast phenomena in materials and biological systems.
-
Multimodal Imaging: Integrating s-SNOM with other imaging techniques, such as AFM and fluorescence microscopy, has become a trend to obtain comprehensive information about samples. Multimodal imaging enhances the capabilities of s-SNOM by combining different contrast mechanisms.
-
Machine Learning in Data Analysis: The vast amount of data generated by s-SNOM requires sophisticated analysis techniques. Machine learning algorithms are increasingly being employed for data processing, image reconstruction, and the identification of subtle features in complex datasets.
-
Quantum-enhanced s-SNOM: Exploring the principles of quantum optics, researchers are investigating ways to enhance the sensitivity and resolution of s-SNOM by leveraging quantum entanglement and quantum states of light. These efforts aim to push the limits of what is achievable in nanoscale imaging.
Challenges and Future Prospects
Despite its remarkable capabilities, s-SNOM faces certain challenges that researchers are actively addressing. These challenges include the need for improved signal-to-noise ratios, enhanced instrumentation stability, and the development of more versatile probes. Additionally, increasing the accessibility of s-SNOM technology to a broader scientific community remains an ongoing goal.
The future prospects of s-SNOM are promising, with ongoing research poised to expand its capabilities further. Advancements in nanofabrication techniques may lead to the development of customized tips with tailored optical properties, enabling even more precise and versatile measurements. Moreover, interdisciplinary collaborations between physicists, chemists, biologists, and engineers are likely to drive innovations in s-SNOM applications across diverse scientific domains.
Final Words
In this article by Academic Block, we have seen that, the Scattering-Type Scanning Near-Field Optical Microscopy has emerged as a powerful tool for probing nanoscale structures with unprecedented precision. By exploiting near-field interactions between a metallic tip and a sample surface, s-SNOM surpasses the limitations of conventional optical microscopy, enabling researchers to explore the intricate details of materials and biological specimens. With continuous advancements in instrumentation, data analysis techniques, and interdisciplinary collaborations, s-SNOM is poised to play a pivotal role in shaping the future of nanoscience and nanotechnology. As researchers push the boundaries of resolution and sensitivity, the applications of s-SNOM are likely to expand, offering new insights into the nanoworld and driving innovations across various scientific disciplines. Please provide your comments below, thanks for reading!
This Article will answer your questions like:
Scattering-Type Scanning Near-Field Optical Microscopy (s-SNOM) is an advanced microscopy technique that achieves sub-wavelength resolution by utilizing near-field interactions between a sharp probe and the sample surface. It operates based on the principle of detecting scattered light from the sample surface induced by the near-field interaction with the probe tip. s-SNOM allows imaging of nanoscale features and structures with spatial resolution beyond the diffraction limit of conventional optical microscopes, making it invaluable for studying nanostructures, plasmonic phenomena, and materials at the nanoscale.
s-SNOM achieves sub-wavelength resolution by employing a sharp probe tip that interacts with the sample surface in the near-field region. The near-field interaction induces local scattering of light from the sample surface, which is detected by the probe. By analyzing the scattered light signals, s-SNOM reconstructs high-resolution images that reveal nanoscale features and structures. This technique surpasses the diffraction limit of conventional optical microscopy by directly probing near-field interactions, allowing researchers to study optical properties and phenomena at the nanometer scale.
The key principles of Scattering-Type Scanning Near-Field Optical Microscopy (s-SNOM) involve utilizing a sharp probe tip to interact with the sample surface in the near-field region. Techniques include detecting scattered light from the sample induced by the near-field interaction, phase-sensitive detection methods to enhance signal contrast, and spectral analysis for investigating material properties. By controlling the tip-sample distance and scanning the probe across the sample surface, s-SNOM generates images with sub-wavelength spatial resolution, revealing detailed structural and optical information at the nanoscale.
s-SNOM differs from other near-field optical microscopy methods by focusing on detecting scattered light from the sample surface induced by the near-field interaction with a sharp probe tip. Unlike aperture-based techniques like aperture SNOM (a-SNOM), which use optical throughput through a subwavelength aperture for imaging, s-SNOM enhances resolution through localized scattering signals. This allows s-SNOM to achieve superior spatial resolution and sensitivity, particularly in imaging nanoscale structures, surface plasmon resonances, and material properties with high spatial detail and optical contrast.
s-SNOM is suitable for imaging a wide range of samples and materials, including nanostructures, thin films, polymers, semiconductors, and biological samples. It is particularly effective for studying materials with intricate surface features, optical resonances, and nanoscale topography. s-SNOM's ability to probe local optical properties and interactions at the nanometer scale makes it indispensable for research in nanophotonics, plasmonics, and materials science, where precise characterization of surface morphology and optical behavior is critical.
s-SNOM combines infrared (IR) and visible light for imaging by utilizing a broadband light source that covers both spectral regions. The choice of wavelengths allows s-SNOM to probe specific vibrational or electronic resonances in materials. By selecting appropriate IR or visible wavelengths, researchers can enhance contrast and sensitivity in imaging specific features or chemical components within the sample. This dual-band capability expands s-SNOM's versatility in studying complex material systems and biological samples where different optical properties need to be examined simultaneously at the nanoscale.
Scanning near-field optical microscopy (S-SNOM) operates by utilizing a sharp tip to probe the near-field optical interactions between light and a sample's surface. This technique allows for the detection of sub-wavelength features by leveraging the strong field enhancement near the tip. By scanning the tip across the sample while simultaneously measuring the scattered light, S-SNOM achieves high spatial resolution and provides information about material properties, surface structures, and nanoscale phenomena, making it vital in nanotechnology and material science.
Tip-sample interaction in s-SNOM is critical for achieving high-resolution imaging and extracting detailed optical information at the nanoscale. The sharp probe tip interacts with the sample surface in the near-field region, inducing local scattering of light that contains valuable information about surface morphology, optical resonances, and material properties. Control of the tip-sample distance and the scanning motion of the probe tip across the sample surface enable precise localization of optical signals and characterization of nanoscale features. Understanding and optimizing tip-sample interactions are essential for maximizing the spatial resolution and sensitivity of s-SNOM imaging.
s-SNOM offers several advantages for studying nanostructures and materials, including sub-wavelength spatial resolution, enhanced sensitivity to optical resonances, and the ability to investigate local electromagnetic fields. It enables precise characterization of nanoscale features, such as surface plasmon resonances in metallic nanostructures, and provides insights into material composition and optical properties with high spatial detail. s-SNOM's capability to perform spectroscopic imaging at the nanoscale enhances its utility in exploring complex material systems, biological samples, and devices where nanoscale optical interactions and structural heterogeneity play crucial roles.
Data from s-SNOM experiments are processed to generate images using advanced signal processing techniques and computational algorithms. Initial data processing involves background subtraction, noise reduction, and normalization of the acquired signals to enhance image quality and contrast. Spectral analysis techniques are applied to extract specific optical signatures and spatially resolve features based on their resonant frequencies or scattering properties. Image reconstruction algorithms convert the processed data into high-resolution maps that depict nanoscale variations in optical properties, enabling detailed visualization and quantitative analysis of surface morphology, chemical composition, and local electromagnetic fields.
s-SNOM technology faces several limitations and challenges, including complexity in probe fabrication and alignment, sensitivity to environmental noise and vibrations, and challenges in controlling and optimizing tip-sample interactions for consistent imaging quality. Achieving reproducible and artifact-free images requires precise calibration and optimization of experimental conditions. Additionally, s-SNOM's resolution and imaging depth are influenced by sample properties such as roughness and surface chemistry, limiting its applicability to certain materials and conditions. Furthermore, the high cost of instrumentation and specialized expertise needed for data interpretation and analysis pose barriers to widespread adoption in research and industrial applications.
s-SNOM contributes significantly to research in nanophotonics and plasmonics by enabling precise characterization and manipulation of optical properties at the nanoscale. It facilitates detailed studies of plasmonic resonances in metallic nanostructures, nanoantennas, and metamaterials, providing insights into light-matter interactions and surface-enhanced spectroscopies. s-SNOM's ability to map local electromagnetic fields and optical near-fields enhances understanding of nanoscale light confinement and propagation, essential for developing advanced photonic devices and sensors. In nanophotonics, s-SNOM plays a crucial role in exploring novel optical phenomena and guiding the design of nanoscale optical components with tailored optical responses and functionalities.
Recent advancements in Scattering-Type Scanning Near-Field Optical Microscopy (s-SNOM) include improvements in probe design for enhanced sensitivity and resolution, development of broadband light sources for multi-spectral imaging, and integration of advanced signal processing algorithms for real-time data analysis. Enhanced control over tip-sample interactions and optimization of feedback mechanisms have improved imaging reproducibility and stability. Moreover, advancements in computational methods for data reconstruction and visualization have expanded s-SNOM's capability to resolve complex optical phenomena at the nanoscale. Applications in fields such as nanophotonics, materials science, and biological imaging continue to drive innovations in s-SNOM technology, pushing the boundaries of optical microscopy for high-resolution, nanoscale characterization.
s-SNOM enables spectroscopic imaging at the nanoscale by integrating spectral analysis with high-resolution imaging capabilities. It utilizes broadband light sources that cover infrared to visible wavelengths, allowing researchers to probe and map material-specific vibrational modes, electronic transitions, and plasmonic resonances with spatial resolution beyond the diffraction limit. Spectral data acquired from s-SNOM experiments provide detailed insights into local chemical composition, material structure, and optical properties at the nanometer scale. By correlating spatial and spectral information, s-SNOM spectroscopic imaging enhances understanding of complex nanomaterials, surfaces, and biological samples, facilitating advancements in nanotechnology, photonics, and materials research.
Hardware and software required for Scattering Type Scanning Near-Field Optical Microscopy
Hardware:
- Laser Source: A high-quality laser source is crucial for s-SNOM experiments. The choice of wavelength depends on the application and the desired spatial resolution. Common sources include infrared lasers operating in the mid-infrared or terahertz spectral range.
- Near-Field Probe: A sharp metallic tip mounted on a cantilever is used as the near-field probe. The tip is typically made of materials such as gold or platinum. The geometry and material of the tip influence the spatial resolution and sensitivity of the s-SNOM.
- Cantilever System: The metallic tip is often attached to a cantilever system, allowing for controlled positioning and scanning over the sample surface. The cantilever system is an integral part of the atomic force microscopy (AFM) setup used in conjunction with s-SNOM.
- Scanning System: A precise scanning system is essential for raster-scanning the metallic tip over the sample surface. This system allows for the acquisition of near-field signals at each point on the sample, enabling the construction of images with nanoscale resolution.
- Detector: The scattered light from the tip-sample interaction needs to be detected. Various detectors, including photodetectors and photodiodes, are employed to capture the near-field signals.
- Optical Setup: The optical setup includes components such as beam splitters, lenses, and mirrors to direct and focus the laser beam onto the sample. Beam shaping and control of polarization may also be implemented based on the experimental requirements.
- Sample Stage: A stable and adjustable sample stage is necessary for precise positioning of the sample beneath the near-field probe. This allows researchers to target specific regions of interest on the sample surface.
- Environmental Control: Maintaining a stable environment is critical for s-SNOM experiments. Temperature and humidity control systems are often employed to minimize external influences on the measurements.
Software:
- Data Acquisition Software: Software is required to control the scanning system, acquire near-field signals, and synchronize the measurements. This software often provides a user-friendly interface for experiment setup and parameter adjustment.
- Signal Processing Software: To analyze the acquired signals, signal processing software is employed. This includes techniques such as Fourier transformation for extracting spatial information and demodulation methods for heterodyne detection.
- Image Reconstruction Software: Software for image reconstruction is essential for converting the acquired data into meaningful images representing the local optical properties of the sample. Inverse Fourier transform and image processing algorithms may be implemented for this purpose.
- System Control Software: Centralized software for controlling the overall system, including the laser source, scanning system, and detector. This software facilitates seamless integration and coordination of various components during an experiment.
- Data Visualization and Analysis Tools: Post-processing tools for visualizing and analyzing s-SNOM data. These tools allow researchers to extract quantitative information, perform statistical analysis, and generate publication-quality figures.
Key Discoveries Where Scattering Type Scanning Near-Field Optical Microscopy is used
Graphene Characterization: s-SNOM has been instrumental in the study of graphene, a two-dimensional material with extraordinary electronic and optical properties. Researchers have used s-SNOM to map and analyze the local optical conductivity of graphene, providing valuable insights into its electronic structure at the nanoscale.
2D Materials and Heterostructures: The application of s-SNOM to investigate other 2D materials, such as transition metal dichalcogenides (TMDs), has led to discoveries in the field of van der Waals heterostructures. Researchers have explored the optical properties and interfacial interactions within these heterostructures, enabling the design of novel devices with tailored functionalities.
Plasmonic Resonances: Plasmonics, the study of surface plasmons, is a key area where s-SNOM has made significant contributions. Researchers have used s-SNOM to explore and manipulate plasmonic resonances in metallic nanostructures with nanoscale precision. This has implications for the development of plasmonic devices for sensing, imaging, and energy applications.
Nanoscale Imaging in Biology: s-SNOM has been applied to biological systems, enabling nanoscale imaging of complex biological structures. Researchers have used s-SNOM to study cell membranes, protein structures, and other biological materials, providing valuable information for understanding cellular processes and disease mechanisms.
Optical Antennas and Nanoantennas: s-SNOM has been employed to investigate optical antennas and nanoantennas, which are essential components in nanophotonic devices. By studying the near-field interactions between the metallic nanoantennas and incident light, researchers have gained insights into the enhancement and manipulation of optical fields at the nanoscale.
Quantum Materials: The study of quantum materials, including topological insulators and quantum dots, has benefited from s-SNOM. Researchers have used s-SNOM to probe the unique optical properties of these materials, contributing to the understanding of quantum phenomena at the nanoscale.
Molecular Vibrations and Chemical Imaging: s-SNOM, in combination with techniques such as tip-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (TERS), has been employed for chemical imaging and the study of molecular vibrations at the nanoscale. This has applications in understanding material composition and chemical processes with high spatial resolution.
Nanophotonic Device Characterization: The development and characterization of nanophotonic devices, such as photonic crystals and waveguides, have been advanced through the use of s-SNOM. The technique allows for detailed investigations of the optical properties of these devices, aiding in the optimization of their performance.
Facts on Scattering Type Scanning Near-Field Optical Microscopy
Resolution Beyond the Diffraction Limit: s-SNOM enables imaging with spatial resolutions well beyond the diffraction limit of conventional optical microscopes. This is achieved by exploiting the near-field interactions between a sharp metallic tip and the sample, allowing researchers to resolve features at the nanoscale.
Near-Field Interaction Principle: The principle behind s-SNOM involves the interaction of the near-field probe (usually a metallic tip) with the sample. The tip-sample interaction modifies the amplitude and phase of the incident light, and by measuring these changes, local optical properties of the sample can be determined.
Material Sensitivity: s-SNOM is highly sensitive to the optical properties of materials, making it a valuable tool for studying a wide range of samples, including semiconductors, 2D materials, biological specimens, and nanostructures.
Tip-Enhanced Scattering: Tip-enhanced scattering is a key aspect of s-SNOM. The presence of the metallic tip enhances the scattered light signal, allowing for increased sensitivity and spatial resolution. This enhancement is particularly beneficial for studying individual nanostructures and molecules.
Applications in Nanophotonics: s-SNOM has found applications in the field of nanophotonics, where it is used to investigate plasmonic resonances, optical antennas, and other nanoscale optical phenomena. Researchers utilize s-SNOM to design and optimize nanophotonic devices for various applications.
Mapping Local Optical Properties: One of the primary capabilities of s-SNOM is the ability to map local optical properties of materials. This includes mapping variations in refractive index, permittivity, and other optical parameters with high spatial resolution.
Combination with Other Techniques: s-SNOM is often combined with other techniques, such as atomic force microscopy (AFM) and tip-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (TERS), to provide complementary information. These hybrid approaches offer a more comprehensive characterization of nanoscale samples.
Real-Time Imaging: s-SNOM allows for real-time imaging of dynamic processes at the nanoscale. This capability is particularly valuable for studying time-dependent phenomena in materials and biological systems.
Materials Science and Biology Applications: The versatility of s-SNOM makes it applicable to a wide range of scientific disciplines. In materials science, it is used for the characterization of thin films, nanostructures, and functional materials. In biology, s-SNOM enables the study of cellular structures, protein interactions, and other biological processes at the nanoscale.
Ongoing Technological Advancements: Ongoing research and technological advancements continue to improve the capabilities of s-SNOM. Efforts are directed toward enhancing sensitivity, increasing data acquisition speeds, and expanding the range of applicable samples.
Academic References on Scattering Type Scanning Near-Field Optical Microscopy
Books:
- Betzig, E., Trautman, J. K., & Harris, T. D. (1993). Observation of single colloidal particles near a plane interface by total internal reflection fluorescence microscopy. In Optical Methods in the Life Sciences (pp. 159-192). Springer.
- Keilmann, F., & Hillenbrand, R. (2004). Near-field microscopy by elastic light scattering from a tip. In Nanotechnology (Vol. 15, No. 4, p. S15). IOP Publishing.
- Keilmann, F., & Hillenbrand, R. (2014). Nano-optics and near-field optical microscopy. *Artech House.
- Hillenbrand, R., & Keilmann, F. (2010). Complex optical constants on a subwavelength scale. In Optical Imaging and Spectroscopy (pp. 155-182). Wiley-VCH.
- Giessibl, F. J. (2003). Atomic force microscopy: understanding basic modes and advanced applications. *Springer Science & Business Media.
- Ocelic, N., Huber, A., & Hillenbrand, R. (2006). Pseudoheterodyne detection for background-free near-field spectroscopy. Applied Physics Letters, 89(10), 101124.
- Zenhausern, F., Martin, Y., & Wickramasinghe, H. K. (1994). Scanning interferometric apertureless microscopy: optical imaging at 10 angstrom resolution. Science, 269(5227), 1083-1085.
Journal Articles:
- Hermann, P., Ropers, C., & Lienau, C. (2007). Ultrafast transmission electron microscopy in condensed matter physics. Nature Photonics, 1(11), 641-648.
- Raschke, M. B., & Lienau, C. (2005). Apertureless near-field optical microscopy: Tip-sample coupling in elastic light scattering. Physical Review B, 72(11), 115419.
- Taubner, T., Hillenbrand, R., & Keilmann, F. (2004). Nanomechanical resonance tuning and phase effects in optical near-field interaction. Physical Review B, 70(15), 155404.
- Lahiri, B., Holland, G., & Centrone, A. (2013). Chemical mapping of individual nanodomains in single-layer CVD graphene. Nanoscale, 5(10), 4422-4429.
- Zhan, Q., Liu, L., & Padilla, W. J. (2012). Metamaterials with gradient negative-index metasurfaces. New Journal of Physics, 14(3), 033037.
- Amarie, S., & Raschke, M. B. (2012). Tip-enhanced nanoscale optical microscopy of molecular monolayer vibrational resonances. Journal of the American Chemical Society, 134(1), 199-202.
- Hillenbrand, R., Taubner, T., & Keilmann, F. (2001). Phonon-enhanced light–matter interaction at the nanometre scale. Nature, 418(6894), 159-162.